kb.pub

📖 READER VIEW (Read-Only, Public Access)

My attic feels very cold in the winter and hot in the summer. I suspect the insulation is old and insufficient and would like to explore an upgrade.

Session publiqueSession #34313/01/2026👁️ 19 vues
🤖

AI Analysis Summary

The user is experiencing extreme temperature fluctuations in their attic, with it being very cold in winter and very hot in summer. They suspect their current insulation is old and insufficient.

Problèmes

My attic feels very cold in the winter and hot in the summer. I suspect the insulation is old and insufficient and would like to explore an upgrade.

Questions

5 questions
Q1

What type of insulation is currently in your attic (e.g., fiberglass batts, blown-in cellulose, spray foam)? (ID: 1839)

It appears to be primarily fiberglass batts. They're the pinkish-red kind, and they're laid down between the joists. In some areas, it looks like there might be a very thin layer of something else underneath, but the bulk of it is definitely fiberglass batts.

Q2

When was the insulation last inspected or added to? (ID: 1840)

I'm not entirely sure when it was last inspected or added to. The house was built in the late 1970s, and I suspect the insulation is original to the house. I haven't done anything with it since I moved in about five years ago, and I don't recall the previous owners mentioning any upgrades.

Q3

Can you describe the general condition of the insulation (e.g., is it compressed, wet, or does it have visible gaps)? (ID: 1841)

The insulation looks pretty sad, to be honest. It's mostly fiberglass batts, and they're definitely compressed in a lot of areas, especially where they've been disturbed over the years. There are also some visible gaps and thin spots, particularly around the edges and where the joists are. I haven't noticed any signs of wetness or mold, thankfully, but it's certainly not uniform or well-distributed.

Q4

Do you notice any drafts or air leaks around attic access points or light fixtures? (ID: 1842)

Yes, definitely! I can feel cold air seeping in around the attic hatch, especially when the wind blows. There are also a few older recessed light fixtures that seem to be letting in drafts. I've even seen dust motes dancing around them on windy days.

Q5

What is the approximate R-value of your current attic insulation, if known? (ID: 1843)

I honestly have no idea what the R-value of my current attic insulation is. I've never had it tested or measured. It's probably quite low, given how poorly it performs.

Causes identifiées

3 causes
#1

Insufficient Insulation Thickness

90%

The existing insulation may not be thick enough to provide adequate thermal resistance, leading to heat transfer in both directions. This is a common issue with older homes or if insulation hasn't been updated to current standards.

#2

Air Leaks and Gaps

80%

Unsealed gaps and cracks in the attic floor or around penetrations (like light fixtures, plumbing vents, and attic hatches) allow conditioned air to escape and unconditioned air to enter, bypassing the insulation.

#3

Degraded or Compressed Insulation

75%

Over time, insulation can settle, compress, or become damaged, reducing its effectiveness. This can happen due to foot traffic, moisture, or simply the natural aging process of the material.

Solutions recommandées

6 solutions
💡

Professional Insulation Assessment

98%Official
Have a professional energy auditor or insulation contractor assess the current R-value and recommend the appropriate type and amount of insulation to add.

🤖 AI Analysis

"The user has no idea about their current R-value and suspects the insulation is old and performing poorly. A professional assessment is the most crucial first step to accurately diagnose the problem, determine the current R-value, identify specific issues, and recommend the most effective course of action, whether it's adding insulation, air sealing, or replacing damaged sections. This will guide all subsequent decisions."

💡

Air Sealing

95%Official
Seal all visible gaps and cracks in the attic floor and around penetrations using caulk, spray foam, or weatherstripping before adding insulation.

🤖 AI Analysis

"The user explicitly mentions feeling drafts around the attic hatch and recessed light fixtures, indicating significant air leakage. Air sealing is a critical prerequisite to effective insulation, as drafts bypass insulation and significantly reduce its performance. Addressing these leaks will immediately improve comfort and prevent conditioned air from escaping into the attic."

💡

Add More Insulation

90%Official
Install additional layers of insulation on top of the existing material to achieve the recommended R-value for your climate zone.

🤖 AI Analysis

"Given the age of the house (late 1970s) and the description of compressed and gapped fiberglass batts, it's highly probable that the existing insulation is insufficient for modern energy efficiency standards. Adding more insulation on top of the existing, after addressing air sealing and any damaged areas, is a common and effective way to increase the R-value and improve thermal performance."

💡

Replace Damaged Insulation

85%Official
Remove and replace any insulation that is wet, moldy, or severely compressed. Ensure the underlying cause of damage (e.g., roof leak) is addressed first.

🤖 AI Analysis

"The user describes the insulation as 'compressed in a lot of areas' and having 'visible gaps and thin spots.' While not explicitly stating it's wet or moldy, severe compression and gaps significantly degrade insulation performance. Replacing severely damaged or compressed sections, especially if they are beyond repair by fluffing, would be necessary for optimal performance. The user should also be advised to check for underlying causes of damage if any are found."

💡

Insulate Attic Hatch

80%Official
Ensure the attic access hatch is properly sealed and insulated to prevent significant air leakage.

🤖 AI Analysis

"The user specifically mentions feeling cold air seeping in around the attic hatch. Insulating and sealing the attic hatch is a direct and impactful solution for a common source of air leakage and heat loss/gain, directly addressing one of the user's stated problems."

💡

Fluff or Re-distribute Existing Insulation

40%Official
For some types of insulation, gently fluffing or re-distributing it can help restore some of its insulating properties, though replacement is often more effective.

🤖 AI Analysis

"The user describes the fiberglass batts as 'compressed' and having 'gaps and thin spots.' While fluffing might offer a minor improvement in some areas, the description suggests the insulation is significantly degraded. Replacement or adding new insulation is likely to be far more effective than simply trying to re-distribute old, compressed batts. This solution is less relevant given the described condition."

Aider les autres