📖 READER VIEW (Read-Only, Public Access)
The user is experiencing difficulty adhering to their trading strategy, specifically by holding losing trades for too long. They are seeking guidance on creating a robust trading plan and effectively implementing stop-loss orders.
I'm currently trying to follow a strategy based on moving averages and RSI. The idea is to enter trades when the price crosses a certain moving average and the RSI is in an oversold or overbought territory, signaling a potential reversal or continuation. I look for confirmation signals, but the execution is where I falter. I'll enter based on the signals, but then when the price fluctuates, I lose conviction and deviate from the plan.
When a trade starts moving against me, my immediate reaction is usually panic and denial. I'll tell myself, 'It's just a temporary dip,' or 'It'll come back.' I start to feel a knot in my stomach, and my focus shifts from the strategy to trying to 'fix' the losing trade. I might even consider adding to the losing position, which is a terrible idea. It's a cycle of anxiety and poor decision-making.
I have some vague ideas about exit criteria, but they're not concrete or consistently applied. For winning trades, I usually have a profit target in mind, but I often get greedy and let winners run too far, only to see them reverse. For losing trades, this is where I really struggle. I don't have pre-defined stop-loss levels. Instead, I tend to move my stop further away or just hope the price will bounce back. It's reactive, not proactive.
Honestly, my risk tolerance is all over the place, which is part of the problem. When I'm feeling confident, I might be willing to risk 2-3% of my account on a single trade. But when I'm feeling nervous or chasing losses, I've definitely risked more, sometimes even 5% or more, which is way too high. I *know* I shouldn't, but it happens. Ideally, I want to be disciplined and stick to a maximum of 1% per trade, but I'm not there yet.
Right now, my tracking is pretty haphazard. I mostly rely on my broker's platform to see my P&L, but I don't really log individual trade details like entry/exit points, the reasoning behind the trade, or the specific indicators I used. I'll occasionally look at my overall account balance to see if I'm up or down, but a formal review process is definitely lacking. It's more of a 'glance and hope for the best' situation.
The user may be experiencing emotional biases like hope or fear, preventing them from objectively cutting losses when a trade goes against their plan. This can lead to holding onto losing positions in the hope they will recover.
🤖 AI Analysis
"The user explicitly describes significant emotional responses like panic, denial, anxiety, and poor decision-making when trades move against them. They also admit to holding onto losing positions too long due to these emotions. Emotional journaling directly addresses this by helping them identify and understand these patterns, which is crucial for developing coping mechanisms and sticking to their strategy."
🤖 AI Analysis
"The user struggles with sticking to their strategy and often deviates due to fluctuating conviction and emotional responses. Pre-trade rituals can help reinforce the trading plan and objective analysis before entering a trade, which could mitigate some of the emotional influence and impulsive decisions that lead to holding losing trades too long. However, it's less direct than emotional journaling for addressing the core issue of emotional reactions *during* a trade."